Me against eight sales coaches · Scored by Claude, Anthropic’s AI

Who should you hire, me or them?

I’m not going to tell you the other guys are no good. Most of them are good. I’m going to tell you what each one is built for, what I’m built for, and where they beat me. Then you pick.

Here’s the short version. Every coach on this list was a salesperson, and some were great ones. I was the salesperson, then the owner. I built the list, wrote the pitch, hired kids off the street, paid them, trained them, fired the ones who wouldn’t dial, and signed the deals myself when a rep couldn’t. Four of those kids got to a million dollars or close to it. If you want someone who’s been in your chair, as the rep and as the owner, that’s the difference. If you want a software specialist, a famous name or a course you can do at midnight, some of them beat me, and I say so below.

Joe Piazza
US$19Msold by phone, no brand behind it
2,200+companies booked, 35 summits
4reps I hired at zero who got to US$1M or close
NadiaBarinderJohnyChrishNadia US$1,375,700 · Barinder US$1,229,000 · Johny US$2,591,000 · Chrish US$954,000

Prices and offers are what each coach’s own website showed on November 3, 2026. They change; check their site. The scores are Claude’s opinion from those pages and my records, not an audit., theirs and mine.

Tell me what you're looking for

Type it the way you'd say it to a friend. What you sell, how you sell it, where it goes wrong. I'll tell you if I'm a great fit, a good fit, or the wrong guy, and who to call instead.

Or pick one:

All nine of us, side by side

Two scores each, because the honest answer depends on what you need. “Their buyer” is who that coach built the offer for. “My buyer” is phone, cold, no brand, or you own the company.

CoachBuilt forPrice seen Nov 3, 2026Works your real calls?Owned a sales team?Them, for their buyerMe, for their buyerMe, for my buyerThem, for my buyer
Collin CadmusB2B SaaS reps and foundersUS$1,000–2,000 a sessionYesNot established9595
Marcus ChanB2B owners, US$2M–30M, 2–20 repsUS$50,000 first 90 daysYesCorporate sales leader, then consultancy8786
John BarrowsB2B teams and repsUS$497/yr to US$7,500Yes (ELITE)Not established9485
Ian KoniakEnterprise tech sellersUS$2,997 to US$48,000/yrDeal reviewCoaching company9384
Dan OakesSaaS founders, first 20 customersUS$350/hr; US$6,000 sprintNot statedNo7684
Josh BlumIn-home home improvementUS$997 to US$5,000Not statedNot stated8382
Rebecca KildayWomen in salesUS$5,000 for 6 weeksNot statedFranchise owner, by her account7684
Lois CreamerProfessional speakersUS$500/hr; US$7,500+Not statedRan speakers’ businesses9483
Joe PiazzaPhone, cold, no brand. Owners who sell it themselves.The Power Hour, one at a time or in fives and tens; the price is on the agreementYes, every hourYes. Built it, owned it, ran it: US$19M sold——8.3 avg4.1 avg

Averages: on their turf, they score 8.3 and I score 4.8. On mine, I score 8.3 and they score 4.1. That’s the whole page in two lines. The call is where you find out whose turf you’re on.

One at a time, honestly

What they do, what they charge, where they beat me, where I beat them. Nothing here comes from anywhere but their own pages and my own records.

Collin Cadmus

Built for B2B software reps, leaders and founders · collincadmus.com

What he doesOne-off sessions: US$1,000 for an SDR, US$1,500 for an AE, US$2,000 for a leader, 60 minutes each, with your calls and emails reviewed in advance. Founder retainers US$1,000 to US$4,000 a month. Fifteen-plus years running SaaS sales teams, by his account.
Where he beats meIf you sell software with a demo, a CRM and an SDR team, he lives in that world and I don’t. He also built a big audience, so you can see him think before you pay.
Where I beat himI didn’t sell with a brand behind me. I sold sponsorships to CEOs who’d never heard of us, cold, on the phone, and then I taught people with zero experience to do it. He coaches the rep. I coach the rep and the owner, because I was the owner.

Him for his buyer 9Me for his buyer 5Me for mine 9Him for mine 5

Marcus Chan, Venli Consulting

Built for B2B owners with US$2M–30M in revenue and 2–20 reps · venliconsulting.com

What he doesA 90-day “Revenue Engine OS”: US$10,000 for month one, US$20,000 a month after that, US$50,000 for the first 90 days. A US$2,000 private founder session. Ran a 110-person sales org at Cintas, by his account, and says 700+ clients since.
Where he beats meHe’s done this 700 times with a written system and a plan at the end. I’m starting my mentoring practice from zero clients, and I say that out loud.
Where I beat himHis first 90 days cost US$50,000. Ten Power Hours with me cost a fraction of that, and all ten are me. His team coaches your deals; I built a team. When your rep’s deal is dying, I take the call and close it with them listening. And I’ll take you below US$2M, because deal size never mattered to me; the problem did.

Him for his buyer 8Me for his buyer 7Me for mine 8Him for mine 6

John Barrows, JB Sales

Built for B2B sales teams and reps · jbarrows.com

What he doesA US$497-a-year membership. ELITE at US$7,500 for three months with six private sessions and call reviews. Teams from US$7,500. Dedicated training US$25,000 and up. Salesforce, LinkedIn, Google and Amazon on the client list and “more than 100,000 sales reps” trained, by his account. 410+ verified G2 reviews at 4.8. Fees non-refundable once started.
Where he beats meBrand, scale, content, and 417 reviews you can read. He can train 50 reps at once with a platform behind it. I can’t and won’t. His own reviewers say the content leans software.
Where I beat himHours with me are all with me, on your calls. His US$7,500 buys six sessions plus videos; ten of mine cost about the same. And he never owned the company whose reps he trained. I did.

Him for his buyer 9Me for his buyer 4Me for mine 8Him for mine 5

Ian Koniak, Untap Your Sales Potential

Built for enterprise technology sellers · untapyoursalespotential.com

What he doesA one-year, non-cancelable membership: US$2,997 self-study, US$12,000 group, US$24,000 with a certified coach, US$48,000 Platinum with twelve private hours with Ian. Extra hours with Ian US$2,000. Former #1 enterprise AE at Salesforce with US$100M+ in career sales, by his account.
Where he beats meHe was the top rep at one of the biggest software companies on earth. Enterprise software, big-company procurement, seven-figure deals. Not my world.
Where I beat himHe sold with the biggest brand in software behind him. I sold with none. Different sport. His private hour is US$2,000, and you have to buy the year first. Mine is one Power Hour, no commitment, at half that.

Him for his buyer 9Me for his buyer 3Me for mine 8Him for mine 4

Dan Oakes, Startup Sales Consulting

Built for software founders getting their first 20 customers · on Leland

What he doesUS$350 an hour. A US$6,000 four-week founder outbound sprint with 15 to 30 coaching hours, a 90-minute kickoff, weekly 45-minute sessions and unlimited Slack. “Satisfaction guaranteed or don’t pay the full amount.” 18 reviews at 5.0. First sales hire at two startups, by his account.
Where he beats meCheapest on this list by the hour, a written guarantee, and the modern outbound stack that startups need. I did it with a phone and a list.
Where I beat himHe never owned the company and never closed at volume. I built the list, the pitch and the team, and the team sold US$19M. If your problem is “I don’t have enough people to talk to,” I’ll have you on the phone in hour one.

Him for his buyer 7Me for his buyer 6Me for mine 8Him for mine 4

Josh Blum, Josh Blum Sales Academy

Built for in-home home-improvement and construction reps

What he doesUS$997 self-study, US$2,500 with three months of messaging, US$5,000 Elite with three 60-minute Zoom calls and six months of messaging. Ten-plus years at the kitchen table, by his account. No refund policy published.
Where he beats meIn-home residential selling, financing, the contractor world. I’ve never sold a roof to a homeowner.
Where I beat himI sold the roofing manufacturers. BASF’s roofing division bought from me seven times. If you sell B2B, commercial or over the phone, that’s mine. And ten hours with me is ten hours, not three calls and a text thread.

Him for his buyer 8Me for his buyer 3Me for mine 8Him for mine 2

Rebecca Kilday, Sell INSPIRED

Built for women in sales

What she doesUS$5,000 for six weeks, one private 45-minute call a week. Twenty years in sales and a franchise owner, by her account. All sales final.
Where she beats meThat’s her community and her lane, and she built it on purpose. I don’t pretend to be the right fit for everyone.
Where I beat herNadia and Barinder each sold over a million dollars for me, cold, on the phone, with zero experience when they started. That’s not a program for women in sales. That’s two women who became million-dollar closers in my office. Ask them.

Her for her buyer 7Me for her buyer 6Me for mine 8Her for mine 4

Lois Creamer, Book More Business

Built for professional speakers · bookmorebusiness.com

What she doesUS$500 an hour with a two-hour minimum. Two-day intensives at US$7,500, US$9,500 and US$12,500 with 30, 60 or 90 days of follow-up. Consulting with speakers since 1998.
Where she beats meThe speaking business: bureaus, fees, positioning for the stage. Not my trade, and twenty-eight years is twenty-eight years.
Where I beat herIf your problem is picking up the phone and getting the decision, I did that for 13 years and US$19M. A speaker who has to cold-call meeting planners is making a phone sale. That’s mine.

Her for her buyer 9Me for her buyer 4Me for mine 8Her for mine 3

Joe Piazza, The Closer Maker

Built for anyone who sells on the phone or Zoom, cold, with no brand, and for owners who sell it themselves

What I doOne-on-one, on Zoom, on your real calls. The Power Hour, one, five or ten at a time. Packages can be tailored to your specific needs. Hours include the time I spend listening to your calls. One free 30-minute call first, so neither of us wastes money.
My recordBuilt FMA Summits from a website and a phone. US$19M sold, 2,200+ companies booked, 35 summits. Hired kids with zero experience; Nadia, Barinder and Johny each passed US$1M, Chrish got to US$954,000. Retired at 38.
For you ifYou sell live on the phone or Zoom and can’t close. You’re the owner, the closer and the whole sales team. You’ll put me on your real calls.
Not for you ifYou want another course. You want scripts without live reps. You don’t sell by phone. You want a cheerleader, not a mentor.
The testOne Power Hour is US$1,000. You decide what we cover. If you don’t hear the exact moment your deal tipped, on your own call, don’t book a second one.
Where they beat me, all of themI have no mentoring clients to show you yet. My proof is what my own reps did, and you can’t read it on G2. I’ve never sold software, residential or anything with a demo. I’ve been out of the chair since 2015. I’m one guy: no app, no course, no community, maybe ten clients at a time. Every one of those is a fact, not modesty.

Me, for my buyer 8.3Me, for theirs 4.8

Julio
“Sales success starts with the person, not the pitch. You weren’t just my boss. You were a mentor.”
Julio, hired by Joe at FMA in 2014, read his letter

Why I put this page up

Because every sales coach’s site says he’s the best, and you can’t tell. I’d rather you read eight honest comparisons, pick the right guy, and come back to me when the problem is the one I fix: you sell on the phone, nobody’s heard of you, and the deal dies between “interested” and signed. Or you own it, you sell it all yourself, and you need people who can.

  • Every price here was on the coach’s own site on November 3, 2026. Prices change. Check theirs.
  • Their results are their own claims. So are mine, except where I’ve put the emails and the masterlist up for you to read.
  • The scores are Claude’s, Anthropic’s AI, from those pages and my records. Not an audit., theirs and mine.
  • Nobody on this page paid to be here or asked to be. If one of them thinks I got a fact wrong, email me and I’ll fix it the same day.

Still not sure whose turf you’re on? That’s what the call is for.

Every month your reps can’t close is another deal somebody else signs. Whatever your deal size, the math is the same.

Thirty minutes. Tell me what you sell and where the deal dies. If I’m not the right guy, I’ll tell you which one of these eight is, and you’ll owe me nothing.

Scored by Claude, Anthropic’s AI, on November 3, 2026, from each coach’s public pages and Joe Piazza’s records. Opinions, not an audit. Not affiliated with or endorsed by any coach named here.

Application received

Your answers are in.

Next step: your call with Joe

Watch your phone. Joe reads it himself and gets back to you to set your call time.

Great, I’m glad you see the value, and I’m looking forward to working with you. Here’s what happens next: I read your answers myself, get back to you to set your call, and on the call we pick your start day. While you wait, start with the scripts from my book first.

Get the scripts

Want to put it to work with me?

Three ways in, all one on one with me: the Power Hour, Power Owner, Power Owner Build. Every one starts with thirty minutes, free.

See the three ways in
Joe Piazza

Joe PiazzaThe Closer Maker

Before you go

I love no. A no means you made a decision.
So tell me: what’s stopping you from saying yes right now?

Don’t want to type? I’ll give you thirty minutes. Tell me yourself.

Your information

A clear exchange.

When you request my book, The Closer Maker, Joe Piazza collects your email and any first name you choose to provide to record your request and give you access to the book.

You choose the follow-up

The optional checkbox is permission to send you sales lessons and information about Joe’s coaching. You can get the book without checking it. If you opt in, marketing emails must include a way to unsubscribe.

Private mentorship requests

If you apply for mentorship, the details you submit are used to review your application and respond about the program. A phone number is optional and is used only if you request contact about your application. Applying does not subscribe you to a separate marketing list.

Storage and service providers

Submissions are stored by the operator of this website. If an email or customer-management service is connected, it may process the details needed to fulfill your request. This site loads Google and OpenAI ad tags so I can see which ads bring people here. No Meta pixel. I never sell your form submissions. Book download links expire after 24 hours; you can request a fresh copy using the form.

Anonymous page statistics

The site counts anonymous clicks, such as which button was pressed, to learn which parts help visitors. No names, contact details or cookies are used for this.

Questions or deletion requests

You can request access to or deletion of your submitted information below. Use the email address associated with your request. A deletion request requires identity verification before records are removed.

Inside The Closer Maker

A page from The Closer Maker

Book 30 minutes with me
Joe’s story

Loading my story…

Thirty minutes with Joe

Bring me the call. Thirty minutes on Zoom, on me.

  • The call. You and me on Zoom. Bring one recorded call, yours or a rep’s, or we do one live. I show you exactly where the deal is lost.
  • The purpose. To find the real problem. Not the one you name. The one under it. Then what I’d do about it, built for your situation.
  • The sequence.
    1. Four short screens, so the thirty minutes is about you.
    2. Pick your time in the calendar. The Zoom link comes by email right away, and a reminder an hour before.
    3. Show up.
    4. You get one email: what I saw, and one next step. Then decide.

Have a question first?

30-minute call with Joe